07:17 am, Thursday 18 December, 2008
Source: Gold Coast News
A truck driver who was on the phone to his mother when he caused a crash that killed one person and injured nine has been jailed for a year.
Although he had shed tears earlier, Michael Robert Hogan, 37, of Kyogle, showed little emotion yesterday when told he would be sent to prison.
Hogan, who pleaded guilty, appeared in the District Court at Beenleigh for sentencing on a charge of dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing death and grievous bodily harm.
The charges followed an incident involving the prime mover he was driving, and six other vehicles, on the M1 at Yatala in July, 2006.
Outside court yesterday, crash victim Patrick McCue, who was severely injured in the incident, said he felt the sentence was too lenient.
Attorney-General Kerry Shine, after being told of the one-year sentence by The Bulletin, said he would request a copy of the judge’s sentencing remarks.
A spokesman for Mr Shine said the Attorney-General would peruse the material to see whether there were grounds for an appeal. Mr Shine has 28 days to appeal.
The court was told Hogan was transporting a load of household rubbish north on the M1 when his truck careered into southbound lanes, across a vegetated centre median strip, colliding with oncoming traffic.
During the crash, which a witness had previously described as like ‘a bomb going off’, Erin Schuster, 24, was killed and Mr McCue, an Energex worker, seriously injured.
Eight others were also injured but the court heard emergency workers and the families of those involved in the incident had also been gravely affected.
Witnesses said Hogan appeared to make no attempt to straighten the truck or brake as he crossed on to the wrong side of the motorway.
The crash also caused the closure of southbound lanes of the motorway for up to five hours.
Yesterday morning, Hogan arrived at court flanked by family and supporters, more than an hour before his hearing was due to begin.
He wore a dark suit and dark tie, as he silently made his way into the court house. A sombre mood prevailed in the courtroom as accident victims, their families and Hogan’s supporters sat stony-faced in the public gallery as the hearing began.
In arguing for a jail term of three to four years, Crown Prosecutor Megan Heywood said there was strong evidence to suggest Hogan, who had been a professional truck driver for most of his adult life, had been speaking on a mobile phone to his mother at the time of the crash.
“As the driver of a heavy vehicle he assumed the risk of talking on a mobile phone,” she said.
“The defendant must have known that it was dangerous.”
In asking for leniency, barrister Charlie Bagley said Hogan had suffered psychological distress to the point he had attempted suicide twice in the aftermath of the incident.
The court also heard Hogan, who sustained head injuries in the crash, could remember nothing about the crash, including whether he had been speaking on a mobile phone.
During the hearing, Mr Bagley offered an apology to the victims and their families on Hogan’s behalf.
Judge Ian Dearden repeatedly described the consequences of the ‘classically and clearly preventable’ crash as ‘catastrophic’.
After reading several victims’ impact statements, Judge Dearden acknowledged Hogan’s remorse, good driving record and lack of criminal history before imposing the three-and-a-half year sentence, with only 12-months to be served in actual custody.
He also said Hogan and his family had suffered along with the victims and their families.
Hogan was also disqualified from driving for four years.
Mr McCue, speaking outside court, said he thought the sentence seemed lenient.
“Twelve months does seem like a fairly light sentence for killing someone and destroying so many lives and you’ve got to think that if Carl Williams would have run over his victims instead of shooting them, he might be out on the street now,” he said.
Also outside court, mother and daughter, Sandra Eastwood and Renee Cole, who were also both injured in the crash, said they were struggling to forget.
“I remember every graphic detail,” said Ms Cole who was pregnant at the time of the crash. “We relive it most days of our lives … we just have to get on with it.”
OHS News Tip: Safe Work Method Statement
Report by Julia Alder - Do you have an OHS News Story - Let us know